How to Combine Manual and Automated Testing in Jira

When manual and automated tests are managed separately, teams retest work that automation has already covered and lose sight of what was actually verified. This guide explains how to combine manual and automated testing in Jira so both report against the same test cases, steps and results.

Manual testing is often laborious and time-consuming, and not always effective at finding certain classes of defects. Test automation can run those tests quickly and repeatedly, which makes it a cost-effective way to protect software quality over a long maintenance life. Yet tests are frequently automated with little visibility, so teams end up retesting manually because nobody can see what the automation covered.

Why manual and automated testing drift apart

Even organisations with mature automation spend significant time investigating automated test logs. The cause is usually a disconnect between the original manual test case design and what the automated test actually verified.

The problem grows when there are two or more separate testing teams:

  • Test analysts, the manual testing team, who design tests and execute them manually before handing them over for automation.
  • Test engineers, the automation team, who develop, execute and support the automated tests.

Automation should not change your standards for test execution and reporting. Nobody should feel automation is a mysterious process because they cannot see confirmed coverage against the steps the test analyst designed.

Manage both from one platform

The recommended approach is to manage automated tests in the same platform the rest of the project team uses for manual testing, such as Atlassian Jira. When you package a set of test cases, for example your regression suite, both the manual testers and the automation solution execute and report from the same suite in your test management system.

As automated coverage grows, manual effort should reduce towards your intended automation target. That frees the testing team to focus on results and on the tests and issues that have not been automated.

How to combine manual and automated testing in Jira

The aim is readable test scripts that both manual testers and automation engineers can manage and support. With Vansah Test Management for Jira, the workflow looks like this:

  1. Design the test in Jira. Manual testers define the steps and expected results against a Jira issue or test cycle.
  2. Verify the test manually. Run the test by hand first, capturing actual results and detailed logs that the automation team can reference.
  3. Build the automated script against the same test case. Automation engineers construct the script from the manual design and link it to the test case through the automation framework of their choice.
  4. Report results step by step. Each test case step is identified by its step number against the case linked to the Jira issue, and automated runs pass or fail steps through the Vansah API using an API token generated from Jira.
  5. Review manual and automated results together. Because both write to the same test case, one report shows overall status regardless of how each test ran.

For implementation detail, see the Vansah API framework tutorial and API documentation. Our guide on integrating automated test results into Jira covers the wider pipeline setup.

Signs your manual and automated testing are working together

A combined approach is working when the whole team trusts a single view of testing.

Check that your team has:

  • One regression suite used by both manual testers and automation
  • Automated scripts built from, and linked to, documented test cases
  • Step-level automated results recorded against each test case
  • Evidence and execution comments attached to automated results
  • A single report showing manual and automated status for each release
  • Manual effort reducing as automated coverage grows

Testpoint’s test automation services help teams build frameworks that connect to Jira test management, so automation adds visible, trusted coverage rather than a separate stream of results.

Want manual and automated testing in one view?

Tell us about your Jira setup, your automation tools and where results are getting lost between teams. We will help you design a combined approach your whole team can trust.

Book a consultation